Advice Hub

Cultural Fit vs. Skill Set: What Matters More in Finance Hiring?


When hiring in finance, decision-makers often grapple with whether to prioritise a candidate’s skill set or their alignment with the company’s culture. The finance sector, known for its complexity and fast-paced environment, requires a nuanced approach to recruitment. Here, we explore both sides of the argument, advocating for a balanced perspective that considers the multifaceted nature of success in the industry.

The Case for Skill Set:

  • Indispensable Technical Skills: Finance and accounting roles demand a specific set of skills, from detailed financial analysis to compliance with evolving regulatory standards. These skills are the bedrock upon which the industry stands.
  • Ready to Hit the Ground Running: Candidates with a strong skill set can dive into their roles with little to no downtime, immediately impacting the team’s performance and productivity.
  • Flexibility and Future-Readiness: In an industry characterised by constant change, professionals with a comprehensive skill base can adapt more swiftly, embracing new technologies and methodologies with ease.

The Case for Cultural Fit:

  • Harmony and Collaboration: A candidate who shares the company’s values and ethos is more likely to gel with the team, fostering a collaborative environment that is essential for innovation and problem-solving.
  • Engagement and Retention: Employees who feel a deep connection with the organisation’s culture often show higher levels of job satisfaction and loyalty, reducing turnover and fostering a stable, committed workforce.
  • An Embodiment of Company Values: Individuals who resonate with the company’s ethos serve as ambassadors, both within and outside the organisation, enhancing the company’s reputation and attracting like-minded talent.

Striking the Right Balance:

Embracing a balanced approach to hiring in finance means recognising that both skill set and cultural fit play pivotal roles in the long-term success of an organisation.

  • A Blended Strategy: Successful finance teams balance technical excellence with a shared commitment to the company’s values and goals. This holistic approach ensures not only operational efficiency but also a positive, cohesive workplace culture.
  • Tailored Recruitment: Understanding the unique dynamics and needs of each organisation allows for a more targeted recruitment process, aligning candidates’ skills and personal attributes with the strategic objectives and cultural nuances of the company.
  • Ongoing Development and Integration: Support doesn’t stop at hiring. Cultivating an environment where skills are continuously developed and cultural integration is encouraged ensures that employees remain engaged and productive.

The debate between cultural fit and skill set isn’t about choosing one over the other but about recognising the value of both. In the finance sector, where precision meets people, the synergy between a candidate’s technical abilities and their alignment with company culture can catalyse not just individual careers but also the growth and resilience of the organisation as a whole.

More from our Advice Hub


Salary Guides: As Useful as Waterproof Teabags

3 min read
Published 1 month ago

At We Do Group, we believe salary guides are completely pointless. In fact, they are as useful as waterproof teabags!
The Allure of Salary Guides
Recruiters love them! It’s almost like they...

Read More

Xero Crowned the King of Finance Systems for SMEs

2 min read
Published 4 weeks ago

The results from our recent poll are in! We were curious about which finance system small to medium enterprises (SMEs) prefer. So, we turned to our LinkedIn audience for their insights, and here...

Read More

Our New Podcast: The Recruitment Playbook

Read More

The Recruitment Playbook – Episode 4

Read More

Addressing Concerns About Job Hoppers

“I’m sorry, but they’re just too jumpy.”

I hear this frequently from hiring managers...

Read More

How to Market Yourself as an Interim Finance Professional

3 min read
Published 4 months ago

Navigating the waters of interim finance requires more than just a keen sense of numbers and analysis; it demands a proactive stance in marketing oneself. Let’s delve into practical...

Read More