Advice Hub

How to Ask for a Pay Rise in Your Year-End Review

Insights

It’s review season. Diaries are filling up with “quick catch-ups” that are anything but quick. Managers are looking back at the year, objectives are being discussed, and somewhere in there is the conversation everyone secretly cares about.

Money.

Most people walk into their annual review hoping. Hoping their manager has noticed the extra work. Hoping there’s a bit more in the budget. Hoping they won’t actually have to bring up the subject of a pay rise. And we get it. Talking about money can feel awkward. But here’s the thing…

Hope is a lovely thing. It’s just not a negotiating strategy.

If you think you deserve a pay rise, you need to be ready to explain why. So, here’s how to ask for a pay rise in your year-end review without making the whole thing unnecessarily uncomfortable.

End of year review - payrise

Know What You’re Worth Before You Walk In

You can’t ask for the right number if you don’t know what the right number is. And we’re not talking about what your mate earns, what someone on LinkedIn claims they’re making or what you reckon you should be getting because everything costs more these days. We’re talking about what the market is actually paying. Start by looking at similar finance roles in your area. What are businesses offering for someone with your experience, qualifications and responsibilities? Check current job adverts, look at salary guides and speak to a recruiter who sees real offers being made every week.

Our We Do Salary Benchmark service is a useful starting point for understanding finance salaries and benefits in the current market. And be realistic about what’s happening out there.

According to ACCA’s January 2026 recruitment report, recruiters across the UK and Europe generally expected salary increases of between 2% and 5% for most roles, with larger increases more likely for harder-to-find skills. The latest ONS earnings figures also show annual regular pay growth of 3.7% across Great Britain in the three months to August 2026. That’s a measure of average earnings growth, rather than the typical pay rise an individual employee receives, but it gives some useful context.

Does that mean you shouldn’t ask for more than 5%?

Absolutely not. If you’ve taken on significantly more responsibility, developed specialist skills or discovered your salary is well below market rate, you’ve got a stronger case for a bigger increase. But if you’re asking for 20%, you’ll need a very good reason. Or a very new job title.

Build Your Case Like a Month-End Pack

You’re a finance professional, you know the importance of numbers, you wouldn’t send a board pack with no figures in it, so don’t walk into your salary review armed with nothing more than “I’ve worked really hard this year.” We’re sure you have, but so has everyone else.

The trick is showing the difference you’ve made. Think about what you’ve delivered over the past 12 months.

  • Have you shortened the month-end close from eight days to five?
  • Improved cash collection or reduced outstanding debt?
  • Identified cost savings?
  • Made forecasting more accurate?
  • Implemented a new finance system?
  • Taken on additional responsibilities while someone else was off or a vacancy remained unfilled?
  • Or perhaps you’ve started managing people, supporting a second business entity or taking on work that wasn’t part of your original job description.

Write it all down. And wherever possible, put a number against it.

There’s a big difference between saying: “I’ve taken on loads more responsibility this year.”

And:

“I’ve taken responsibility for the management accounts across two entities, reduced our month-end close by three days and helped improve reporting accuracy.”

One is an opinion. The other is evidence.

Make it easy for your manager to see the value you’re bringing to the business.

Because even if they agree you deserve a pay rise, they might need to justify that increase to someone else. Give them something useful to work with.

Timing Matters More Than You Think

Here’s something people often forget. By the time your annual review comes around, the salary budget might already have been decided. Not always. But in plenty of businesses, pay reviews and budget planning happen before the actual performance conversations. Which means you could walk into your review with the world’s greatest argument for a pay rise, only to discover the money has already been allocated.

Frustrating? Absolutely. Avoidable? Sometimes.

Our advice? Don’t wait until the review to start thinking about it.

Ask your manager how salary reviews work.

  • When are budgets agreed?
  • Who signs off pay increases?
  • Is there a formal process?

And if your review is already booked, don’t assume you’ve missed your chance. Find out whether decisions have been finalised and what options are still available. The earlier you understand the process, the better prepared you’ll be.

Ask for a Number, Not “a Bit More”

This is where people get nervous. You’ve done the research, you’ve pulled together your achievements, you’ve explained why you deserve more. And then you say something like:

“So, I was just wondering whether there might be any chance of maybe looking at my salary?”

We’ve all been there. But vague questions tend to get vague answers.

Be clear about what you’re asking for.

If you’re currently earning £48,000 and your research suggests that £53,000 is reasonable for your role, experience and responsibilities, say so. Explain where the figure has come from. Make it clear you’re not simply plucking a number out of thin air.

You might say:

“Based on the additional responsibilities I’ve taken on this year, the results I’ve delivered and what similar roles are paying in the market, I’d like to discuss increasing my salary to £53,000.”

Simple, professional, no dramatic speech required. Aim towards the top of a realistic salary range, but make sure you can justify it. Your manager might agree. They might suggest a different figure. Or they might need to take the request away for approval.

And once you’ve made your case?

Stop talking. Seriously. Silence feels incredibly long in these meetings, let it be long. You don’t need to fill every second by explaining why you’d also be happy with less.

Have a Plan for “No”

Sometimes the answer is no. Or “not right now.” Or the classic: “Let’s revisit this in six months.” Not exactly the response you were hoping for, but it doesn’t have to be the end of the conversation. The important thing is understanding why.

  • Is it a budget issue?
  • Does your manager think you need more experience?
  • Are there specific objectives you need to achieve?
  • Or is the business simply not in a position to increase salaries?

Don’t leave the meeting without understanding what happens next.

Ask what would need to change for a pay rise to be considered. Agree some measurable objectives. And most importantly, agree when you’ll have the conversation again.

If your manager supports your request but needs approval, ask who makes the decision and when you can expect an answer. Then follow up in writing so there’s a clear record of what’s been discussed. This is consistent with Acas guidance on proposing changes to your employment contract, which recommends being clear about the change you’re requesting, your reasons and when you’d like it to happen.

And remember, salary isn’t the only thing worth discussing. If the budget genuinely isn’t there, think about what else could make a difference. Perhaps the business could fund your ACA, ACCA or CIMA studies. Maybe additional study leave would help.

  • Could your job title better reflect your responsibilities?
  • Would more flexibility, additional holiday or a development opportunity make the role more rewarding?
  • And could you agree another salary review in six months rather than waiting a full year?

None of these is a guaranteed alternative to a pay rise, but they’re worth exploring. Because sometimes the best outcome isn’t simply an extra number on your payslip. It’s getting something that genuinely improves your working life or helps you progress.

Think Twice Before Using Another Job Offer as Leverage

We’ve all heard the stories. Someone asks for a pay rise, the answer is no. They go out, interview elsewhere and suddenly come back with an offer worth £10,000 more. And just like that, their current employer finds some extra money, funny how that happens. But we’d be careful about using another job offer purely as a bargaining chip.

Sometimes it works, but sometimes it creates an awkward situation. And sometimes the reasons you started looking for another job don’t disappear just because your employer offers you more money.

If you’re frustrated by a lack of progression, poor leadership or limited opportunities, will another £5,000 really fix that? Maybe. Maybe not. We’ve written about this in our article, Counter Offers in Finance Recruitment: Why They Rarely Work. It’s worth a read before making any big decisions.

Our advice?

If you want to stay, make your case for a pay rise based on the value you bring.

If you’re genuinely ready to move, explore opportunities because they’re right for your career. Not simply because you’re hoping your current employer will panic and get the chequebook out.

And What If You’re Still Underpaid?

You’ve done your homework, you’ve researched the market, you’ve demonstrated what you’ve delivered, you’ve had the conversation. And the answer is still no. What now?

Well, first, don’t make a decision in the heat of the moment. There might be a genuine reason your employer can’t increase your salary right now. But if you’re consistently being paid below the market rate, your responsibilities keep growing and there’s no clear plan to address it, that’s worth paying attention to. Because staying somewhere should be a choice. Not simply something you do because you’ve been there for years.

And there’s more to a good career move than money… progression, flexibility, leadership, culture and the opportunity to develop all matter too.

If you’re thinking about your next step, take a look at our latest finance and accounting opportunities. You don’t have to apply for anything. Sometimes it’s just useful to see what’s out there. And sometimes the best way to understand what you’re worth is to have a proper conversation with someone who knows the market.

Not Sure What You Should Be Earning?

That’s where we come in. At We Do Group, we spend our days talking to finance professionals and businesses about salaries, career progression and what makes a genuinely good opportunity.

We know what employers are offering, we know which skills are in demand, and we know that sometimes the best career advice isn’t “you should leave.” Sometimes it’s “you’re actually in a pretty good position.”

Our free Salary Benchmark service provides independent salary and benefits insights for finance and accounting roles, helping businesses understand what competitive packages look like. And if you’re a finance professional wondering whether your salary reflects your experience, we’re always happy to have a confidential conversation. Just an honest chat about where you are, what you’re worth and what might come next.

Because knowing your worth is one thing. Being able to explain it is another.

Let’s chat.

hello@wedorecruitment.com
0208 713 8000

More from our Advice Hub

Insights

The Hidden Cost of a Bad Finance Hire (And How to Avoid It)

5 min read
Published 2 years ago
Help wanted sign

Hiring the Wrong Person is More Expensive Than You Think
You need a finance hire.

You rush to fill the role.
You find someone with the right experience on paper.
They interview well enough, so you...

Read More
Insights

From Reporting to Leading: Key Questions to Consider Before Your Next Board Meeting

6 min read
Published 1 year ago
Boardroom

Board meetings aren’t just about presenting numbers – they’re where strategy is shaped, risks are weighed, and future decisions are made.
The best finance leaders don’t just report the...

Read More
Insights

Cultural Fit vs. Skill Set: What Matters More in Finance Hiring?

3 min read
Published 3 years ago

When hiring in finance, decision-makers often grapple with whether to prioritise a candidate’s skill set or their alignment with the company’s culture. The finance sector, known for its...

Read More
Podcast

Our New Podcast: The Recruitment Playbook

Read More
Insights

Why Your Job Ads Are About as Exciting as a Tax Return (And How to Fix Them)

5 min read
Published 2 years ago

Let’s Be Honest – No One Is Excited to Read Your Job Ad
You know that moment when you open your inbox and see a reminder about your tax return? That sinking feeling, the desperate urge to be...

Read More
Insights

Red Flags to Look Out For When Interviewing a Senior Finance Candidate

7 min read
Published 1 year ago
Interview

Hiring a senior finance leader isn’t about filling a gap or finding someone to close month-end. It’s about securing a strategic partner – someone who shapes decisions, protects margins,...

Read More