Advice Hub

Why Your Job Ads Are About as Exciting as a Tax Return (And How to Fix Them)

Insights

Let’s Be Honest – No One Is Excited to Read Your Job Ad

You know that moment when you open your inbox and see a reminder about your tax return? That sinking feeling, the desperate urge to be anywhere else? That’s how candidates feel when they read a bland, jargon-packed job ad.

Most job descriptions read like they were written by a committee of lawyers and accountants who were specifically told to remove anything resembling a personality. “We’re looking for a self-starter with a proven track record of stakeholder engagement, a dynamic approach, and the ability to work in a fast-paced environment.” Translation: We don’t really know what we want, but we’ll be annoyed if you can’t do it.

If your job ad is full of vague buzzwords, a laundry list of unrealistic demands, and zero insight into what makes your company actually worth working for, don’t be surprised if the best candidates scroll past you.

But fear not—we’re here to show you how to inject some life into your job ads and actually attract the people you want.

The 3 Biggest Problems with Most Job Ads (And How to Fix Them)

1. You Sound Like Every Other Company

Take a look at your last job ad. Now Google a similar role and compare. Spot the difference? No? Neither can your candidates.

If your ad sounds like it was copy-pasted from a corporate handbook, you’re blending into the background. And in a competitive hiring market, that’s the last thing you want.

How to fix it:

  • Drop the generic phrases like “fast-paced environment” and “dynamic team.” What does that actually mean for the person reading it?
  • Inject some personality—if your team is lively and collaborative, say so. If your office is all about work-hard-play-hard, be honest about it (without cringey clichés).

Example of a fix:

  • Bad: “We offer a competitive salary and the opportunity to work in a dynamic team.”
  • Good: “You’ll be working with a tight-knit finance team who take their spreadsheets seriously but know when to crack open the Friday beers.”

If your job ad sounds like an actual human wrote it, you’ll instantly stand out.

2. The Laundry List of Unrealistic Expectations

We see it all the time: “Must have 10 years of experience, 3 degrees, and the ability to speak fluent Excel.”

The problem? The perfect candidate you’re describing doesn’t exist. And if they do, they’re probably not applying because they already have six job offers on the table.

When you create a wishlist longer than a Christmas shopping list, you scare off great candidates who might have 80% of the skills but feel they’re not “qualified enough.” Meanwhile, someone who thinks they can do the job (but really can’t) will apply anyway.

How to fix it:

  • Prioritise the top 3-5 must-haves. Be clear on what’s essential vs. what can be learned.
  • Use inclusive language—women and underrepresented groups are less likely to apply if they don’t meet every bullet point.

Example of a fix:

  • Bad: “Must have a master’s degree, 8+ years of experience, and be an expert in 15 different finance software tools.”
  • Good: “You’ll need solid experience in financial reporting and a knack for making sense of numbers—if you’ve worked with Xero or SAP before, great! If not, we’ll get you up to speed.”

Hiring is about potential as much as experience. If you only chase unicorns, you’ll be waiting forever.

3. No One Knows What’s In It for Them

Companies love listing what they expect from candidates but forget to mention why anyone would actually want to work there.

Top talent isn’t just looking for a job; they’re looking for a reason to choose you.

How to fix it:

  • Instead of just listing benefits, sell the experience. What’s exciting about the role? Why is your company great?
  • If you have flexible working, great culture, or cool perks, don’t just say it—explain what it means day to day.

Example of a fix:

  • Bad: “We offer a competitive salary and great benefits.”
  • Good: “We know finance jobs can be demanding, which is why we offer fully flexible working, 25 days of holiday (plus your birthday off), and a bonus structure that actually rewards your hard work.”

If your benefits sound exciting and meaningful, candidates will actually picture themselves working there—which is half the battle.

Bonus Tip: Make It Easy to Apply

  • If you make people jump through hoops just to submit a CV, don’t be surprised when they don’t bother.
  • Ditch the 30-minute application forms. No one wants to re-enter every detail from their CV.
  • Skip the pointless cover letters (most candidates write them just to tick a box).
  • Make sure your process is mobile-friendly—most candidates will see your ad on their phone.
  • If your hiring process is smooth and simple, you’ll get more applicants (and fewer dropouts).

Final Thought: If You Want Great People, Write Like a Great Company

Your job ad is your first impression. If it’s dry, confusing, or full of buzzwords, you’re turning off the exact people you want to attract.

But if it’s clear, engaging, and actually human, you’ll not only get more applications—you’ll get the right ones.

So go on, rewrite that job ad like you actually want someone to apply.

Or better yet—let We Do Group do it for you. We help businesses hire finance talent without the headache.

Ready to find your next star hire?

Let’s chat.

More from our Advice Hub

Insights

Celebrating Dale Owen’s Incredible First Year at We Do Group

2 min read
Published 2 years ago

Let’s take a moment to give Dale Owen some well-deserved recognition for an absolutely amazing first year at We Do Group! Apologies in advance, Dale—I know you’ll hate this attention,...

Read More
Insights

Beyond the CV: Crafting Your Personal Brand in Finance & Accounting

3 min read
Published 2 years ago

Standing out in finance and accounting is about more than a list of qualifications on a CV. It’s crafting a personal brand that highlights your unique value, transforming you from a potential...

Read More
Insights

What Great Finance Directors Do Differently (and Why It Matters to Your Business)

7 min read
Published 8 months ago
People looking at a document

A good Finance Director will keep the business running smoothly.A great Finance Director will help it grow, adapt, and thrive — even in challenging markets.
The difference isn’t in technical...

Read More
Insights

The Job Offer Decision Checklist (That Actually Helps)

3 min read
Published 1 year ago
We Do Group water bottle in New York

You’ve got a job offer!
The excitement hits… then the panic sets in. Suddenly, you’re questioning everything from the role itself to your entire career path. Sound...

Read More
Insights

The Hidden Cost of a Bad Finance Hire (And How to Avoid It)

5 min read
Published 12 months ago
Help wanted sign

Hiring the Wrong Person is More Expensive Than You Think
You need a finance hire.

You rush to fill the role.
You find someone with the right experience on paper.
They interview well enough, so you...

Read More
Video

Reflecting on a Year of Growth: Our Journey So Far

As We Do Group celebrates its first anniversary, it’s a moment that feels both monumental...

Read More